How does tax withholding relate to total tax liability?

Published Mar 12, 2024
Sankey cash-flow chart showing tax withholding

At the end of each simulated year, ProjectionLab computes your total tax liability based on everything that happened in that year. Total tax liability is reflected in the Total Taxes expansion panel in the yearly summary pane:

Total Taxes Metric

Total tax liability is also used for the breakdowns and visualizations on the Tax Analytics page:

Tax Analytics Page

However, total tax liability is not what you’ll see in the Sankey cash-flow chart. That chart depicts the underlying flows that occur like tax withholding, tax return payments and refunds.

While tax liability is computed at the end of each simulated year, whether or not any tax actually gets collected and remitted during that year depends on how you have set up tax withholding on your income sources, which you’ll find in the Tax Handling subsection of the Income form.

For example:

Tax Withholding Input

After each year, ProjectionLab reconciles the total computed tax liability with how much tax withholding actually occurred, and then in the subsequent year you’ll either see a tax return payment or refund. This is mainly to try to mirror how things work in the real world, particularly in the US.

If you’d like to see an option added to automatically compute and withhold exact taxes right away instead, here is an item on the public roadmap you might like to upvote and comment on.

Disclaimer: The content, tools, and resources on ProjectionLab.com are intended solely for informational and educational purposes and should not be construed as professional financial or investment advice. Our materials are designed to provide general guidance and are based on the input and data provided by users. ProjectionLab makes no guarantee of the accuracy, completeness, or applicability of this content to individual circumstances. Effective financial planning and investment involve comprehensive consideration of a wide array of personal financial factors. The tools and resources available on ProjectionLab are aimed at helping users develop an understanding of their financial trajectory. However, they should not be solely relied upon for creating a complete financial plan. We strongly recommend consulting a financial services professional who can provide personalized advice based on your unique financial situation before making any significant financial decisions. While we endeavor to keep the information on ProjectionLab current and accurate, the content may differ from that found on other financial institutions, service providers, or specific product sites. All content and tools on ProjectionLab are provided without any guarantees or warranties of any kind.